Plastic vs. Wood Toilet Seats

Welcome, dear reader! Let’s talk about something that we all use on a daily basis but rarely give much thought to – toilet seats! Specifically, let’s dive into the world of plastic vs. wood toilet seats.

Now, you might be wondering why anyone would bother discussing toilet seats, of all things. But think about it – a toilet seat is something that you use every day, multiple times a day. It’s a crucial part of your bathroom routine, and choosing the right one for your needs is important.

Regarding toilet seats, there are two major materials: plastic and wood. Plastic toilet seats are lightweight, easy to clean, and affordable. Wood toilet seats, on the other hand, are durable, elegant, and provide a warm and natural touch to your bathroom decor.

So, why is it important to choose the right toilet seat? Well, for starters, a poorly fitting or uncomfortable toilet seat can cause discomfort, pain, and even health problems. Also, the wrong type of toilet seat can detract from the overall aesthetic of your bathroom and lower its value.

Whether you’re in the market for a new toilet seat or just curious about the differences between plastic and wood, keep reading! We’re about to dive into everything you need to know about these essential bathroom fixtures.

Plastic vs. Wood Toilet Seats: The Pros and Cons 

Toilet seats are an essential component of any bathroom. They come in a variety of materials, including plastic and wood. Both have their pros and cons. This section unpacks the pros and cons of plastic and wooden toilet seats with a logical comparison at the end.

Plastic Toilet Seats


  1. Affordability. Plastic toilet seats are typically less expensive than their wooden or metal counterparts, making them a budget-friendly option.
  2. Durability. Plastic seats are resistant to scratches and chips and less likely to crack or break than other materials.
  3. Easy to clean. Plastic toilet seats are non-porous, making them easy to clean and less likely to harbor bacteria or stains.
  4. Lightweight. Plastic seats are lightweight and easy to install, which can be particularly useful for those who may have difficulty lifting heavier objects.
  5. Availability. Plastic toilet seats are widely available and come in various colors and styles to match your bathroom décor.


  1. Less aesthetically pleasing. Some people find plastic toilet seats to be less attractive than other materials, which can be a drawback for those who prioritize appearance in their bathroom décor.
  2. Less comfortable. Plastic seats may be less comfortable to sit on than padded or cushioned seats.
  3. Potential for warping. Over time, plastic toilet seats may warp or become misshapen, particularly if exposed to high temperatures or direct sunlight.
  4. Not eco-friendly. Plastic is not a biodegradable material, so plastic toilet seats are not environmentally friendly.
  5. Less durable than other materials. While plastic toilet seats are durable in the short-term, they may not last as long as wooden or metal seats, particularly if they are exposed to harsh chemicals or abrasive cleaning products.
Wooden Toilet Seats 


  1. Aesthetically Pleasing. Wooden toilet seats add a classic and elegant look to your bathroom, and they come in different styles, finishes, and colors to match your bathroom decor.
  2. Comfortable. Wooden seats provide a warm and comfortable seating experience compared to plastic or metal toilet seats, which can be cold and uncomfortable.
  3. Durable. High-quality wooden toilet seats can last for years and withstand daily use, making them a worthwhile investment.
  4. Easy to Clean. Wooden toilet seats are easy to clean and maintain with regular wiping using a mild soap and water solution.


  1. Expensive. Wooden toilet seats are generally more expensive than plastic or metal seats, and their cost can increase depending on the quality of the wood used and the craftsmanship involved.
  2. Prone to Water Damage. Wooden toilet seats can absorb water if they are not properly sealed, leading to cracks, warping, and discoloration.
  3. Susceptible to Staining. Wood can easily get stained from urine or other bodily fluids, making it essential to clean up spills immediately.
  4. Hygiene. Wooden toilet seats may be less hygienic than plastic or metal seats because they are porous and can harbor bacteria if not adequately cleaned.

Comparison Between Plastic and Wooden Toilet Seats 

First of all, let’s talk about aesthetics. Wooden toilet seats tend to look more elegant and sophisticated than plastic ones. They come in various styles, finishes, and colors to match any bathroom decor. Plastic seats, on the other hand, often have a more utilitarian look, and the color options can be limited. If you’re looking to add a touch of class to your bathroom, a wooden seat might be the way to go.

When it comes to comfort, wooden seats have a distinct advantage. They tend to be warmer and more comfortable to sit on than plastic seats, which can be cold and uncomfortable. If you’re someone who spends a lot of time on the toilet (hey, no judgment here!), you might appreciate the added comfort of a wooden seat.

Durability is another factor to consider. While high-quality wooden toilet seats can last for years, plastic seats tend to be more durable overall. They are less likely to warp or crack over time and can withstand more wear and tear than wooden seats. This is especially important if you have kids who might be more likely to slam the seat or use it as a step stool (not that we condone that kind of behavior!).

Both wooden and plastic seats are fairly easy to keep clean when it comes to cleaning and maintenance. Wooden seats can be wiped down with a mild soap and water solution, while plastic seats can be cleaned with any household cleaner. However, wooden seats are more susceptible to water damage than plastic ones. If they are not properly sealed, they can absorb moisture and become discolored or warped. Plastic seats, on the other hand, are water-resistant and less likely to suffer from this type of damage.

Another consideration is hygiene. Wooden seats can be porous, which means they can harbor bacteria if not cleaned properly. Plastic seats, being non-porous, are less likely to trap bacteria and are, therefore, generally considered more hygienic. That being said, as long as you clean your wooden seat regularly and thoroughly, you shouldn’t have any issues with bacteria.

Lastly, let’s talk about cost. Wooden toilet seats tend to be more expensive than plastic ones, although the exact price can vary depending on the quality of the wood and the craftsmanship involved. A plastic seat might be the more practical option if you’re on a tight budget. However, if you’re willing to invest a bit more in your bathroom decor and want a functional and stylish seat, a wooden seat could be worth the splurge.

Choosing the Right Toilet Seat

Choosing the right toilet seat material is important because it can affect the comfort and durability of the seat. Here are some factors to consider when choosing a toilet seat material:

Comfort. The toilet seat’s material can affect the comfort level when using the toilet. For example, cushioned vinyl or foam seats can be more comfortable than plastic or wooden seats.

Durability. Opt for a more durable seat. Plastic seats are generally more durable than wooden ones but are often less expensive.

Style. The material of the toilet seat can also affect the overall style and look of your bathroom. Wooden seats can give your bathroom a more natural, rustic feel, while plastic seats can come in various colors and styles to match your bathroom decor.

Maintenance. Some materials may require more maintenance than others. For example, wooden seats may need to be cleaned and oiled regularly to maintain their appearance and prevent warping.

Hygiene. If you’re concerned about hygiene, look for a material that is easy to clean and disinfect. Plastic seats are often the easiest to clean, while wooden seats may require more effort to keep clean.

Consider these factors when choosing a toilet seat material to find one that fits your preferences and needs.

Read Also: How to Clean Plastic Shower Curtains


What is the Strongest Material for a Toilet Seat?

Regarding toilet seats, materials such as stainless steel, metal alloys, and ceramics are known for their strength and durability. However, these materials are not typically used for toilet seats in residential homes, as they can be expensive and may not be comfortable to sit on for extended periods of time.

For residential toilet seats, plastic is often considered the strongest material. It can withstand frequent use and exposure to water and cleaning agents without warping or cracking. Additionally, plastic seats are typically lightweight and easy to install, which can benefit some people.

Wood seats, however, are not as strong as plastic seats but can still last a long time with proper care. They can be susceptible to scratches, stains, and water damage, but if maintained well, they can provide a comfortable and aesthetically pleasing option for a toilet seat.

While stronger materials are available, plastic is often considered the strongest and most practical option for residential toilet seats.

Which Color is Best for the Toilet Seat?

When it comes to choosing a color for a toilet seat, it ultimately comes down to personal preference and the overall aesthetic of your bathroom. Some popular options for toilet seat colors include white, beige, and gray, as they are neutral and can complement a wide range of bathroom decor styles.

Here are a few things to consider when choosing a color for your toilet seat:

  1. Match your bathroom decor. If your bathroom has a specific color scheme or style, consider choosing a toilet seat color that complements it.
  2. Contrast with the toilet bowl. If you have a white toilet bowl, a colored seat can add a pop of color and visual interest to the space.
  3. Consider the cleaning factor. Remember that darker-colored toilet seats may show stains and discoloration more easily than lighter-colored seats. If you’re concerned about cleaning, a white or light-colored seat may be easier to maintain.
  4. Personal preference. Ultimately, the color you choose for your toilet seat should be one that you like and enjoy looking at. Choose a color that makes you happy, whether it’s a bold, bright color or a subtle, neutral tone.
Is a Wooden Veneer Toilet Seat Sanitary?

Wooden veneer toilet seats can be sanitary as long as they are properly cleaned and maintained. However, wooden veneer toilet seats can be more difficult to clean and sanitize than plastic or ceramic toilet seats, which are non-porous and easier to wipe down.

To ensure proper sanitation of a wooden veneer toilet seat, regularly clean it with a mild soap and water solution, and avoid using harsh chemicals or abrasive scrubbers that could damage the surface. After cleaning, thoroughly dry the seat to prevent moisture buildup and the growth of bacteria.

It is also a good idea to periodically treat the wooden veneer with a sealant or protective coating to help prevent the absorption of moisture or bacteria. This will also help to maintain the appearance of the seat over time.

How Often Should I Change My Toilet Seat?

The frequency of changing a toilet seat can vary depending on various factors, such as the quality of the seat, the level of use, and the maintenance practices.

As a general rule, replace a toilet seat every 5-7 years, even if it appears to be in good condition, because, over time, the seat can accumulate bacteria, mold, and stains that cannot be easily cleaned. Additionally, the hinges and screws that hold the seat in place can become loose, making it unstable and unsafe to use.

However, if your toilet seat shows signs of wear and tear, such as cracks, chips, or discoloration, you may be forced to replace it. If multiple people use the seat or in a commercial setting, you may need to replace it more frequently.

Inspect your toilet seat regularly and replace it whenever it shows signs of damage or wear to ensure hygiene and safety.

Bottom Line 

When it comes to choosing between a wooden or plastic toilet seat, there are a few things to consider. First of all, are you someone who values durability and easy maintenance, or do you prioritize the look and feel of natural wood? Both options have pros and cons, so it depends on what matters most to you.

A plastic seat may be the way to go if you’re all about durability and easy cleaning. They’re generally more resistant to wear and tear and can be easily wiped down with a damp cloth. Plus, they come in various colors and styles to fit your bathroom decor.

If you love the warmth and natural look of wood, a wooden seat may be more your style. They can be a bit trickier to clean and may require more maintenance to keep them looking good, but they add a touch of elegance and charm to your bathroom.

When shopping for a toilet seat, it’s important to read reviews from other customers to get an idea of the quality and comfort of the seat you’re considering. Don’t be afraid to ask for recommendations from friends and family, too!

Ultimately, your toilet seat should be a reflection of your personal style and needs. Whether you go for a plastic seat or a wooden one, make sure it’s comfortable, easy to clean, and fits in with the overall aesthetic of your bathroom. Happy shopping!